Bathtub, Shower, or Both? – Which should be added to a bathroom renovation?
Reading Time: 5 min 29 sec
Chadi
When I started working as a renovation builder in Melbourne, one of the most common questions I faced from homeowners was whether they should have a bathtub, a shower, or both in their bathroom renovation. It’s a challenging decision, and the answer often hinges on lifestyle, available space, and plans.
Over the years, I’ve seen firsthand how the right choice can dramatically improve your daily routine and even boost the value of your home. So, whether you’re aiming for a spa-like retreat or need a practical setup for a busy family, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully. Let me share what I’ve learned from my experience to help you make this important decision.
Pros and Cons of Having a Shower and a Bathtub
When I renovated my first bathroom years ago, I quickly learned that deciding between a shower, a bathtub, or having both is more than just a matter of preference—it’s a choice that can significantly impact your home’s functionality and appeal. Let’s break down the pros and cons based on what I’ve encountered in various projects.
Shower Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Space-Saving: A shower can be the perfect space-saving solution in smaller bathrooms. Over the years, I’ve worked with many compact spaces where a well-placed shower made all the difference, maximizing functionality without sacrificing comfort.
- Convenience: Showers are incredibly convenient for quick, daily use. Many of my clients, especially those with busy lifestyles, have found that a walk-in shower or a shower with a rain showerhead can significantly improve their morning routines.
- Water Efficiency: Personally, I’ve found that showers are more water-efficient than bathtubs. Installing a low-flow showerhead can reduce water consumption while providing a refreshing experience.
- Modern Appeal: A well-designed shower can add a modern touch to any bathroom. Frameless glass showers, for instance, have been a popular choice among homeowners looking to create a sleek, contemporary look.
Cons:
- Limited Relaxation: While showers are practical, they offer different levels of relaxation than bathtubs. I’ve heard from many clients who miss the comfort of a long soak, something a shower can’t replicate at the end of the day.
- Showers are less Appealing for families with young children. Bathing kids in a shower can be tricky, and many parents prefer the ease and safety of a bathtub.
Bathtub Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Relaxation: Nothing quite like soaking in a hot bath to relieve stress after a long day. Bathtubs offer a level of relaxation that showers can’t match.
- Family-Friendly: Bathtubs are great for families with young children. They provide a safe and comfortable space for bathing kids, making bath time easier and more enjoyable.
- Luxury Factor: Adding a bathtub, especially a freestanding or whirlpool tub, can add a touch of luxury to your bathroom. This can be a big selling point if you’re considering resale value down the line.
Cons:
- Space Requirements: Bathtubs take up more space than showers, so they might not be ideal for smaller bathrooms. You must consider whether you have enough room to fit a tub comfortably.
- Water Usage: Filling up a bathtub requires more water than a quick shower. This could lead to higher water bills and isn’t as eco-friendly.
- Less Practical for Quick Washes: If you’re in a hurry, a bathtub is less convenient than a shower. It takes time to fill up, and getting in and out quickly can be a hassle.
Having Both: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Best of Both Worlds: A shower and bathtub allow you to choose between a quick rinse and a relaxing soak. It caters to different needs and preferences, making your bathroom more versatile.
- Increased Home Value: A bathroom with a shower and a bathtub can be a big plus for resale. It appeals to a broader range of potential buyers, especially families.
- Design Flexibility: Both options allow you to create a more luxurious and functional bathroom space. You also have the freedom to design each feature to suit your style.
Cons:
- Space and Cost: The biggest downside is that both require more space and a larger budget. If your bathroom is small or you’re working with a tight budget, there might be other options than fitting both.
- Maintenance: Having a shower and a bathtub means more surfaces to clean and maintain. This can add to your regular cleaning routine, so it’s something to consider if you prefer low-maintenance spaces.
Space Considerations: How Much Room Do You Need?
One of the first things to consider when deciding between a bathtub, a shower, or both is the space in your bathroom. Space can be a limiting factor, especially in older homes or apartments where bathrooms tend to be smaller. Let’s break down what you need to know about space requirements for each option.
For a Shower:
- Standard Showers: A standard shower typically requires about 900mm x 900mm (3ft x 3ft) of space. This is the bare minimum to comfortably move around and shower without feeling cramped. If you’re considering a walk-in shower with no doors or a glass enclosure, you might need more space to prevent water from splashing out.
- Luxury Showers: If you dream of a larger, more luxurious shower with a bench or multiple showerheads, you’ll need at least 1200mm x 1200mm (4ft x 4ft) or more. These larger showers provide extra comfort and accessibility but require more floor space.
For a Bathtub:
- Standard Bathtubs: The average bathtub is about 1500mm to 1700mm long (5ft to 5.5ft) and 700mm wide (2.5ft). This size is typical for most homes and offers a decent space for a relaxing soak. However, fitting a standard tub might require creative planning if your bathroom is small.
- Freestanding Bathtubs: If you’re considering installing a freestanding bathtub, you’ll need even more room. Freestanding tubs often require at least 1800mm x 900mm (6ft x 3ft) of space to accommodate the tub and allow easy access around it. These tubs make a bold statement but do need more space to shine.
For Both a Shower and a Bathtub:
- Shower-Only Option: If you’re short on space, opting for a shower-only setup might be the best choice. You can maximize space with a corner shower or a compact walk-in design, which can fit into tight spots while still providing functionality.
- Tub-Only Option: A smaller or corner tub could be a solution for those who can’t part with a bathtub. These tubs are designed to fit into compact spaces without sacrificing the bathing experience.
- Shower-Tub Combo: A shower-tub combo is another great space-saving option. This setup combines both functions, allowing you to enjoy both benefits without needing a large bathroom.
Your space will ultimately heavily influence your decision. Measure your bathroom carefully and consider how each option fits the existing layout. With the right planning, you can create a functional and beautiful bathroom, regardless of size.
Family Considerations: Which Option is Best for Families with Young Children?
When you have young children, your bathroom needs can differ from those of a single person or a couple. Safety, convenience, and comfort become top priorities, and choosing between a bathtub, a shower, or both can significantly impact your daily routine.
Bathtub: The Family-Friendly Option
For families with young children, a bathtub is often the go-to choice. Here’s why:
- Bath Time Ease: Bathing young children is much easier in a bathtub. It provides a safe space where kids can sit, play, and be washed without worrying about water splashing everywhere. Plus, many kids love bath time—it’s often a fun and calming part of their daily routine.
- Safety: A bathtub can be safer for little ones who aren’t yet steady on their feet. With the option to sit or lie down, there’s less risk of slipping, a common concern in showers. You can also use non-slip mats and cushions to make the tub safer.
- Parent-Friendly: As a parent, bending over a bathtub to wash your child is more comfortable than trying to help them in a shower. It allows you to stay at a manageable height, making the process less straining.
Shower: The Practical Choice for Older Kids
While bathtubs are great for young children, showers can be more practical as your kids grow older:
- Quick and Convenient: Showers are faster, making them ideal for busy school mornings when time is short. Once children are old enough to shower independently, this option becomes a time-saver for everyone in the household.
- Transitioning: As kids grow, they might prefer showers over baths. Showering is also a good way to encourage independence, as children can learn to manage their hygiene routines with less supervision.
- Space-Saving: A shower might be the only option if your bathroom is small. You can still make it child-friendly by installing a handheld showerhead, which is easier for kids.
Having Both: The Best of Both Worlds
If you have the space and budget, having both a bathtub and a shower can offer the ultimate flexibility:
- Adaptability: This setup allows you to cater to different needs as your children grow. Younger kids can enjoy baths, while older ones can transition to showers when ready.
- Family-Friendly: With both options, you can choose what works best depending on the situation. Whether it’s a quick rinse after soccer practice or a relaxing bath before bedtime, having both gives you the freedom to adapt.
- Resale Value: Homes with both a shower and a bathtub often appeal to families, making your bathroom renovation a good investment for the future.
Considerations for Smaller Bathrooms
If space is tight, you might need to compromise:
- Shower-Tub Combo: A shower-tub combo is a practical solution that offers both benefits without taking up extra space. This setup is especially useful in smaller bathrooms where space is at a premium.
- Prioritize Needs: Think about your current needs and plans. If your children are very young, a bathtub might be more important now, but a shower might be more practical in the long run if they’re growing quickly.
In the end, the best choice depends on your family’s specific needs and the space you have. Whether you opt for a bathtub, a shower, or both, making the right decision can help create a bathroom that works for everyone in your home.
Adding a Shower to an Existing Bathtub Setup
If you’re looking to enhance a bathroom that already has a bathtub, adding a shower can be a fantastic upgrade. Here’s how I approach these projects:
Options for Integration
- Shower Over Bathtub: This is a popular solution where the shower is installed above the bathtub. It’s a great way to provide both functionalities without needing extra space. I’ve found this setup to be both practical and space-efficient.
- Separate Shower Area: For a more luxurious approach, consider a separate shower area. This involves creating a dedicated shower space next to the existing bathtub, allowing you to enjoy both features independently.
Design Considerations
- Waterproofing: Ensuring proper waterproofing is crucial. I’ve seen issues arise from inadequate waterproofing, so it’s essential to address this during the renovation to prevent future problems.
- Access and Layout: The layout should ensure easy access to both the shower and bathtub. Consider the bathroom’s flow and how you use each feature to make the space more functional and enjoyable.
Benefits of Adding a Shower
- Increased Convenience: Adding a shower can greatly enhance convenience, providing a quick and practical option when you don’t have time for a bath.
- Enhanced Functionality: A shower-tub combo offers the best of both worlds, making your bathroom more versatile and accommodating various needs.
Before you start planning your new shower, there are a few important factors to keep in mind:
Plumbing
The first thing to check is whether your current plumbing can accommodate a shower. If you have a bathtub, the plumbing is already in place to add a shower. However, you may need to upgrade or adjust the fixtures to handle the additional water flow.
Waterproofing
Proper waterproofing is crucial when adding a shower to your bathtub setup. This includes ensuring the walls surrounding the tub are protected from water damage. You should install a shower surround, tiles, or waterproof panels to prevent leaks and maintain the integrity of your bathroom.
Showerhead Placement
Another key consideration is where to place the showerhead. Typically, it’s installed on the wall above the faucet, but the height and angle should be adjusted to suit your needs. A handheld showerhead is a versatile option, offering more flexibility, especially for washing kids or pets.
Curtains or Glass Doors
To keep water from splashing all over your bathroom, you’ll need to add either a shower curtain or glass doors. Shower curtains are more affordable and easily changed, while glass doors offer a sleeker, more modern look. However, glass doors require more cleaning and maintenance to keep them looking their best.
Accessibility
If you plan to stay home long-term, consider accessibility when adding a shower. Features like grab bars, a non-slip tub surface, and a built-in seat can make the shower safer and more comfortable for everyone, including elderly family members or those with mobility issues.
Choosing between a bathtub and a shower for your bathroom renovation can be tough. Both options have benefits, and what’s right for one person might not be the best fit for another. You’ll need to consider your lifestyle, space, budget, and long-term plans to make the right choice. Here’s how to weigh your options and decide what works best.
1. Consider Your Lifestyle and Daily Routine
Your daily habits play a big role in this decision:
- Shower: A shower might be the better option if you’re always on the go. Showers are quick and efficient, ideal for busy mornings or after a workout. They’re also great if you prefer the refreshing feeling of a fast rinse.
- Bathtub: On the other hand, if you value relaxation and enjoy winding down with a long soak after a hectic day, a bathtub could be more suited to your lifestyle. Bathtubs provide a more indulgent experience, perfect for unwinding and pampering yourself.
2. Evaluate the Space in Your Bathroom
Space is a key factor when deciding between a bathtub and a shower:
- Shower: If your bathroom is smaller, a shower is usually the more practical choice. Showers take up less floor space and can be designed to fit into tight spots, like corners or alcoves. This allows you to maximize the use of your bathroom, making it feel more spacious and functional.
- Bathtub: Bathtubs generally require more room, so they might not be ideal for smaller bathrooms. However, compact options are available if you have the space, and a bathtub is high on your priority list. Just measure carefully to ensure it will fit comfortably in your layout.
3. Think About Future Plans and Resale Value
Plans might also influence your decision:
- Shower: If you plan to stay in your home long-term, consider how your needs might change. Showers are often more accessible for older adults or those with mobility issues, especially when designed with accessibility features like grab bars or a built-in bench. A well-designed shower can also appeal to potential buyers, particularly in homes with modern, sleek bathrooms.
- Bathtub: A bathtub can be a must-have if you’re considering starting a family or already have young children. Bathtubs are often seen as more family-friendly and can be a big selling point for resale, especially for families with small kids. Even if you don’t use a bathtub regularly, having one in the home can be a smart investment for future buyers.
4. Assess Your Budget
Your budget will also play a role in this decision:
- Shower: Installing a shower can be more budget-friendly, particularly if you work with a smaller space. A standard shower with basic fixtures can be quite affordable. However, costs can rise if you opt for luxury features like multiple showerheads or custom tile work.
- Bathtub: Bathtubs can vary widely in price, depending on the style and materials. A basic built-in tub might be relatively affordable, but freestanding or whirlpool tubs can get expensive. Additionally, installing a bathtub might require more extensive plumbing work, which could add to the cost.
5. Personal Preference and Aesthetics
Finally, your taste and the overall aesthetic you want to achieve in your bathroom should guide your choice:
- Shower: If you’re after a modern, minimalist look, a shower might be the way to go. Glass-enclosed showers with sleek fixtures can create a contemporary feel, making your bathroom look stylish and up-to-date.
- Bathtub: For those who prefer a classic or luxurious vibe, a bathtub can be the centrepiece of your bathroom. A beautiful freestanding tub, for example, can add a touch of elegance and serve as a focal point in the room.
Frequently Asked Questions
Showers generally require regular cleaning to prevent mould and soap scum, while bathtubs need periodic deep cleaning to maintain their finish.
You may need to consider a shower-tub combo or creative layout solutions to maximize space.
A handheld showerhead is versatile and convenient, making it ideal for both adults and children.
Consider features like a rainfall showerhead, built-in seating, or high-end tile finishes to elevate the space.
Conclusion
Choosing between a bathtub, a shower, or both for your bathroom renovation involves balancing functionality, space, and personal preferences. The right choice can significantly enhance your daily routine and add value to your home. Whether you opt for the relaxing luxury of a bathtub, the convenience of a shower, or the flexibility of having both, the key is to design a space that meets your needs and fits your lifestyle.
By considering the space you have, your family’s needs, and how you plan to use the bathroom, you can create a functional and beautiful space that you’ll enjoy for years to come.
Like this article?