Is It Worth Renovating a House?
Reading Time: 5 min 29 sec
Chadi
I’ve had plenty of homeowners ask me, “Is it worth renovating, or should we just move?” It’s a big decision, and honestly, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. I’ve worked on renovations where families completely transformed their homes and never looked back. But I’ve also seen cases where, after crunching the numbers, moving made more sense.
Renovating can breathe new life into a home. Your kitchen may feel outdated, or your growing family needs more space. A well-planned renovation can add value, improve functionality, and make your home feel brand new without the hassle of moving. But let’s be real—renovations come with costs, disruptions, and surprises along the way.
So, how is it worth it? Should you invest in upgrading your current home, or is selling and finding something new the better option? In this blog, I’ll walk you through the key things to consider—costs, return on investment, lifestyle needs, and when renovating makes more sense than moving (or vice versa). By the end, you’ll have a clearer idea of what’s right for your situation. Let’s dive in!
Key Reasons People Consider Renovating
After years in the renovation business, I’ve seen homeowners take on projects for all sorts of reasons. Some want to boost their home’s value, while others need a space that works better for their lifestyle. If you’re wondering whether a renovation is worth it, here are some of the most common reasons people decide to renovate.
Increasing Home Value
If you’re thinking about selling in the future, strategic renovations can make a big difference. Kitchens and bathrooms offer a great return on investment. I’ve worked with homeowners who spent $30,000 on a kitchen remodel and saw their home’s value increase by much more when they sold. Smart updates can make your property more attractive to buyers and help you get top dollar.
Improving Comfort & Functionality
Sometimes, a house doesn’t work the way you need it to. Your kitchen may be too cramped, or the living area doesn’t flow well. Renovations can help improve functionality, giving you a space that better suits your lifestyle. I’ve seen firsthand how opening up a floor plan or upgrading a bathroom can make a home feel brand new.
Addressing Structural Issues
Older homes often have hidden problems—outdated electrical wiring, plumbing issues, or foundation concerns. These aren’t the most exciting renovations, but they’re some of the most important. I’ve worked on projects where a small repair turned into a major structural fix, but in the end, the homeowners were glad they tackled it before things got worse.
Energy Efficiency Improvements
With rising energy costs, many homeowners are looking to make their homes more efficient. Installing better insulation, upgrading windows, or adding solar panels can cut down on power bills and make your home more comfortable year-round. I’ve seen families save hundreds a year after making these upgrades, making the investment well worth it.
Lifestyle Changes
Life changes, and sometimes, your home needs to change with it. You may need an extra bedroom for a growing family, a home office for remote work, or wider doorways and ramps to accommodate ageing-in-place needs. I’ve worked on plenty of renovations that helped homeowners stay in the house they love while making it more suitable for their current stage of life.
Whatever your reason for renovating, the key is to make sure the investment is worthwhile—both financially and in terms of comfort.
Factors to Consider Before Renovating
Renovating a home is a big decision, and before diving in, it’s important to weigh all the factors. I’ve worked on projects where renovations made perfect sense, adding value and improving the homeowner’s lifestyle. But I’ve also seen cases where the costs didn’t justify the result. Here are some key things to think about before committing to a renovation.
Cost vs. Return on Investment (ROI)
Not all renovations pay off equally. Kitchens and bathrooms usually bring the best returns. At the same time, highly customized changes (like luxury home theatres) might not add as much value when it’s time to sell. Before starting a project, ask yourself: Am I renovating for resale or personal enjoyment? If you’re planning to sell soon, focus on updates that appeal to buyers, not just your personal tastes.
Emotional Attachment vs. Practicality
I’ve met many homeowners who love their houses and don’t want to move, even if renovations don’t make the most financial sense. If your home holds sentimental value, renovating might be worth it. But if you’re forcing a renovation to make the house “work,” it’s worth considering whether moving to a home that already suits your needs is a better option.
Scope of Renovation
Are you considering minor cosmetic updates or a full-scale remodel? A fresh coat of paint, new flooring, and updated fixtures are easy and affordable ways to improve your home. But major renovations—like removing walls, reworking plumbing, or adding an extension—come with higher costs and longer timelines. Be realistic about what’s needed and whether it’s worth the disruption.
Market Conditions
Real estate markets go up and down, and sometimes selling is a smarter move than renovating. If you’re in a strong seller’s market, you might get top dollar for your home without needing to renovate. On the flip side, if home prices are high and moving isn’t affordable, improving your current space could be the better financial choice.
Legal and Permitting Requirements
Not all renovations are as simple as they seem. Structural changes, electrical work, plumbing updates, and extensions often require permits. Skipping this step can lead to fines or problems if you sell in the future. Before starting any major renovation, check local building regulations or consult a professional to make sure everything is up to code.
Renovating your home can be an exciting journey. For many homeowners I’ve worked with, the benefits far outweigh the challenges. Here are some of the biggest advantages of renovating instead of moving.
Customization & Personalization
One of the best things about renovating is that you get to design a home that fits your lifestyle perfectly. Whether it’s a dream kitchen, a bigger bathroom, or an open-plan living space, you can make changes that truly reflect your style and needs. Unlike buying a new house, where you have to compromise on certain features, renovations allow you to shape your space exactly how you want it.
Potential for Higher Home Value
Strategic renovations can boost your home’s market value. I’ve seen clients who upgraded their kitchens, added a second bathroom, or modernized their outdoor spaces get a significant return on investment when they eventually sold. If done right, renovations can make your home more appealing to future buyers and increase equity.
Avoiding Moving Costs & Hassles
Moving isn’t just expensive—it’s stressful. Real estate commissions, legal fees, stamp duty, and moving expenses all add up. Plus, there’s the hassle of packing, adjusting to a new neighbourhood, and finding schools or amenities. Renovating allows you to avoid all that while still getting a refreshed home.
Enhancing Energy Efficiency
Older homes tend to be less energy-efficient, which means higher utility bills. Renovations give you the chance to upgrade insulation, install energy-efficient windows, add solar panels, or switch to modern appliances that save money in the long run. Many homeowners I’ve worked with have cut their energy costs significantly after making these changes.
Preserving a Prime Location
If you love your neighbourhood, school district, or local community, moving might not be worth it. I’ve worked with many homeowners who chose to renovate rather than leave a location they loved. If your home has good bones but just needs updating, a renovation allows you to stay in the area while improving your living space.
While renovations can be rewarding, they’re not always smooth sailing. Here are some of the biggest challenges homeowners face when taking on a renovation.
High Costs & Budget Overruns
Renovations often cost more than expected. Material prices fluctuate, unexpected repairs pop up, and labour costs can add up quickly. I always advise clients to set aside a contingency budget (at least 10-20% extra) to cover surprises. Otherwise, a dream renovation can quickly turn into a financial headache.
Construction Delays & Disruptions
Living in a construction zone isn’t easy. Depending on the scale of the renovation, you could be dealing with dust, noise, and workers in your home for months. If you have young kids or pets or work from home, this disruption can be a major downside.
Limited Return on Investment
Not all renovations add value. Highly personalized upgrades (like custom-built home offices or luxury spas) may not appeal to future buyers. I’ve seen homeowners spend big on renovations, only to find that their home’s resale value didn’t increase as much as they expected.
Potential Structural Challenges
Older homes can have hidden issues—outdated wiring, weak foundations, or plumbing problems—that only show up once work begins. These unexpected challenges can push timelines and budgets beyond what was originally planned. Before starting a major renovation, a thorough inspection is always a good idea.
Outgrowing the Space Regardless
Sometimes, a renovation just isn’t enough. If your home is too small for your long-term needs, no amount of remodelling will fix that. I’ve had clients invest in renovations only to realize a year later that they still need to move. Before renovating, it’s important to think long-term and ensure the changes will truly do your homework for you.
Deciding whether to renovate or move is a big choice. I’ve worked with many homeowners who were torn between these options, and in some cases, staying put and renovating made the most sense. Here’s when it’s usually the better option:
If the Location is Perfect
Finding the right location is tough, and if you’re already in a great spot—close to work, good schools, family, or amenities—it may not be worth leaving just because your home needs some updates. Many of my clients have chosen to renovate to avoid moving out of a neighbourhood they love.
When Renovation Costs Are Lower Than Buying a New Home
The cost of moving isn’t just about buying a new house—it includes real estate fees, stamp duty, moving expenses, and potential renovations on the new home anyway. Suppose the cost of renovating is significantly lower than upgrading to a new property. In that case, it might be the smarter financial decision.
If the Home Has Good Bones
Some houses are just built well. Suppose your home has a solid foundation, a functional layout, and quality construction. In that case, it’s often worth upgrading rather than starting fresh. Simple updates like modernizing kitchens, bathrooms, or flooring can completely transform a house while keeping its structural integrity.
If Market Conditions Favor Renovation
Housing markets fluctuate. If home prices are high and movingrequirese stretching your budget, investing in renovations might be a more affordable way to get the home you want. I’ve seen homeowners renovate strategically during seller’s markets to build more equity before eventually upgrading in a buyer’s market.
While renovating has its benefits, sometimes moving is the more practical choice. Here are some situations where selling and starting fresh might make more sense:
If Renovations Are Too Costly
Some renovations get expensive fast, especially when structural changes, major plumbing, or electrical work are involved. If the cost of fixing up your home is approaching (or exceeding) the cost of buying a newer home, moving could be the better investment.
When Space Needs Exceed What Renovations Can Provide
A renovation can improve a home, but it can’t always add enough space. If you need extra bedrooms, bigger outdoor areas, or a more functional layout, sometimes it’s easier to find a home that already meets those needs rather than forcing major structural changes.
If the Neighborhood No Longer Fits Your Needs
Even with renovations, the surrounding area won’t change. If your commute is too long, the schools aren’t a good fit, or your neighbourhood’s vibe isn’t what it used to be, moving might be the best option for long-term happiness.
If You Need to Move Quickly
Renovations take time, and if you’re in a rush—whether for work, family reasons, or financial changes—selling and buying a move-in-ready home might be the faster solution. I’ve had clients start renovations only to realize they needed to move anyway, leading to wasted time and money.
If you’re still unsure whether to renovate or move, asking yourself the right questions can help you make a clear decision. Over the years, I’ve helped many homeowners weigh their options, and these are the key factors that can guide you:
What is My Budget, and How Much am I Willing to Invest in Renovations?
Renovations can add up quickly. Before jumping in, get a realistic estimate of costs, including materials, labour, and unexpected expenses. Compare that to what you’d spend on selling, buying, and moving. If your renovation budget gets too close to the price of a better home, it might not be worth it.
How Long Do I Plan to Stay in This House?
If you see yourself staying for at least five to ten years, renovations can be a great investment. But if you’re considering moving in a couple of years, ask yourself if you’ll see a return on your renovation costs when you sell.
Will the Renovations Improve My Quality of Life?
Beyond financial considerations, think about your daily comfort. Will a renovated kitchen, extra space, or modernized features make a big difference? If your current home is causing frustration, a well-planned renovation could be the solution.
How Much Will the Renovations Increase My Home's Value?
Not all renovations add equal value. Kitchens, bathrooms, and energy-efficient upgrades tend to have the highest return on investment. But some projects, like overly customized designs or luxury additions, may not bring the same resale value. Do your research to ensure your investment makes financial sense.
What is the Real Estate Market Like in My Area?
If home prices are high and demand is strong, selling might be a great opportunity. On the other hand, if the market is slow or competitive, staying and renovating could be the smarter choice. Understanding local market trends will help you make a more informed decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Kitchen and bathroom upgrades, open floor plans, energy-efficient improvements, and curb appeal enhancements tend to add the most value.
It depends on the project scope, but kitchen or bathroom remodels can take 4–8 weeks, while full-house renovations may take several months.
For major projects like structural changes or full-home remodels, moving out temporarily may be necessary. Smaller updates can often be done while living in the home.
Get multiple quotes, plan for unexpected costs (set aside 10-20% extra), and work with experienced contractors who can provide a detailed breakdown.
Conclusion
Deciding whether to renovate or move is a big choice that depends on your personal needs, financial situation, and long-term goals. Renovating can add value, improve comfort, and save you the hassle of moving, but it also comes with costs, disruptions, and potential risks. On the other hand, selling and moving may be the better option if your home no longer meets your needs or if renovation costs outweigh the benefits.
Before making a decision, take the time to assess your budget, the real estate market, and how much value renovations will truly bring. Think about whether staying in your home long-term makes sense or if a fresh start elsewhere is the better move.
If you’re unsure, consult with a renovation expert or real estate professional to get tailored advice based on your home and financial situation. The right choice is the one that best supports your future plans and lifestyle.
Like this article?